Nova Parks Proposed Regulations W&OD Trail

Proposed regulations: https://susmo.org/media/fr2pkqq4/proposed-wod-park-regulation-no-20_102126.pdf

Send feedback to: 

  1. ExecutiveOffice@nvrpa.org,
  2. WOD@nvrpa.org,
  3. feedback@nvrpa.org


Dear NOVA Parks Board Members:


Thank you for your stewardship of the Washington & Old Dominion Trail, an extraordinary public asset that connects communities and makes walking, bicycling, recreation, and everyday transportation possible for so many Northern Virginians. I also appreciate your public service and the work required to maintain such a heavily used trail. I recognize that unsafe and inconsiderate behavior by some trail users is a genuine problem and that NOVA Parks has a responsibility to address it.


I regularly use the W&OD trail as I bike around Arlington and Northern Virginia and all three of my children use the W&OD to bike to school. We appreciate the efforts to make the trail safer, but are concerned about two aspects of the proposed regulations: the restrictions based on the type of electric bicycle or other device a person rides, and the provisions that could reinforce enforcement of problematic stop signs. I also urge the Board to reconsider the proposed trail hours and to prioritize physical improvements that reduce conflicts between users.


Electric bicycles: regulate behavior, not appearance or device category


We need to recognize the context in which these rules are being proposed. Public education, product labeling, retail practices, and regulation have not kept pace with the proliferation of electric bicycles and electric motorcycles marketed to families. Many parents bought Class 3 e-bikes or e-motos for children without clear, reliable information about their legal status or appropriate use, often because these devices seemed like an affordable alternative to driving or other transportation. This does not excuse dangerous riding, but it matters when designing a fair response.


A categorical device restriction can turn an otherwise careful, courteous rider into an offender without any evidence of unsafe behavior. It can also invite police involvement based on an officer's impression of what a bicycle looks like, even though e-bike classes are not readily distinguishable by sight. That discretion creates risks of mistaken stops and disproportionate enforcement against young people and other vulnerable members of our community. We should be particularly cautious when adopting rules that expand the grounds for police encounters. 


The better focus is on observable conduct: excessive or unsafe speed for conditions, reckless passing, failure to yield, intimidation, and endangerment. The proposed regulation already addresses dangerous behavior, which can be enforcement in the case of a crash. NOVA Parks can reinforce those standards through education, clear signage, targeted enforcement of actual unsafe conduct, and design improvements without treating every rider of a particular category of bicycle as a safety threat.


Stop signs: consistency with Virginia law and traffic-control standards


The stop-sign provisions also raise serious rule-of-law concerns. Virginia Code § 46.2-924(E) specifically addresses when localities may require users of shared-use paths to stop at crossings without traffic-control signals, subject to adoption of a local ordinance. Nova Parks does not have the authority to adopt such an ordinance. Separately, 24VAC30-315-10(A) expressly applies the National Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) to bicycle trails open to public travel. The MUTCD restricts STOP signs used in conjunction with operating traffic signals, subject to defined exceptions.  Nova Park should not be placing stops signs where the law does not require trail users to stop.


NOVA Parks has placed STOP signs at W&OD crossings in circumstances that appear inconsistent with these requirements. Signs that direct trail users to stop even when a traffic signal permits them to cross are particularly baffling: they create conflicting instructions rather than clarity. Before creating or strengthening penalties for failure to obey signs, NOVA Parks should undertake a review of the legal authority its STOP sign and its compliance with the applicable MUTCD provisions. The Board should also explain how the proposed rule interacts with Virginia Code § 46.2-924(E) (recognizing that the Attorney General's June 2013 opinion, which predates that provision).


Trail hours and equity


I am also concerned about the proposed 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. trail hours. A fixed 9 p.m. closure is not obviously tied to darkness or a demonstrated safety threshold; in winter, it becomes dark hours earlier. People traveling on the trail at night may include workers with late shifts, people without access to a car, and others for whom the trail is a critical transportation route. For example, I need to take the trail to travel home from PTA meetings, which end at 9pm. Closing the trail at night can push people biking onto roads where they face greater exposure to motor traffic during particularly dangerous times. NOVA Parks assess the transportation and equity impacts and consider whether narrower measures would address any documented problems.


Invest in solutions that reduce conflict


There is a proven way to reduce conflicts among people traveling at different speeds: provide separate space. NOVA Parks' dual-trail improvements in Falls Church demonstrate the value of separating faster-moving users from walkers and other slower-moving trail users. Expanding dual-trail sections in Arlington and other congested corridors should be a priority, alongside better crossing design, predictable rules, education, and enforcement of dangerous behavior.


I urge the Board to retain and strengthen behavior-based safety provisions, reconsider categorical device bans and the proposed hours, review the legality of existing STOP signs before expanding their enforcement, and commit to a plan for dual-trail expansion. The W&OD is too important as both a recreational resource and a transportation corridor to adopt rules that may undermine access and trust without a demonstrated safety benefit.


Thank you again for your service and for considering these comments.


Sincerely,

Gillian Burgess



--

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

APS Long Term Planning Before Career Center Development

Support for Automated Speed Enforcement in Innovations subcommittee in VA House - 2/1/2024

Oct 2021 Comments on Clarendon Sector Plan